Worth Reparing? 09 Astra XE
My astra has 130k kms (80k miles) and is in need of some repairs:
1. Timing belt due (how far can I push it?)
2. New struts <- my mechanic might be over exaggerating the need to fix this
3. Rear shocks leaking <- my mechanic might be over exaggerating the need to fix this
4. Front breaks and rotors
5. Set of summer tires
I was quoted $3200 CAD to fix all this from a mechanic.
From what I can tell, a 2009 Astra goes for ~$2000 CAD on the high end with the millage I have on it so far.
I'm at a loss as to what to do as I can't really afford a $3200 repair. I'm considering driving into the ground but with the low KM, it seems like a waste if my belt were to go.
If I were to keep up repairs on the Astra, how many miles/km could I expect, generally speaking, to get out of it?
The car feels solid otherwise, just normal maintenance items that have come up.
I'd like to try fix some of this myself this summer. I am not a mechanic by any means and would be learning. I do my own oil changes, replaced spark plugs, change my own tires, changed the coil pack and have replaced an axel on a Toyota. I'd be at the mercy of youtube tutorials and help from fine people like you. I'm a seasoned professional computer tech and have an eye to troubleshooting and fixing things. I generally trust myself, though I would consider myself an amateur when it comes to fixing vehicles.
What would you do in my situation? Looking for honest feedback!
1. Timing belt due (how far can I push it?)
2. New struts <- my mechanic might be over exaggerating the need to fix this
3. Rear shocks leaking <- my mechanic might be over exaggerating the need to fix this
4. Front breaks and rotors
5. Set of summer tires
I was quoted $3200 CAD to fix all this from a mechanic.
From what I can tell, a 2009 Astra goes for ~$2000 CAD on the high end with the millage I have on it so far.
I'm at a loss as to what to do as I can't really afford a $3200 repair. I'm considering driving into the ground but with the low KM, it seems like a waste if my belt were to go.
If I were to keep up repairs on the Astra, how many miles/km could I expect, generally speaking, to get out of it?
The car feels solid otherwise, just normal maintenance items that have come up.
I'd like to try fix some of this myself this summer. I am not a mechanic by any means and would be learning. I do my own oil changes, replaced spark plugs, change my own tires, changed the coil pack and have replaced an axel on a Toyota. I'd be at the mercy of youtube tutorials and help from fine people like you. I'm a seasoned professional computer tech and have an eye to troubleshooting and fixing things. I generally trust myself, though I would consider myself an amateur when it comes to fixing vehicles.
What would you do in my situation? Looking for honest feedback!
mine is about to be due, found a 30 min how to on an opel on youtube so i'm wondering if someone with little to zero experience could tackle this kind of job or there are too many factors to take in consideration lol. I'll look in other threads but your comment resonated with the shenanigans i'm up to.
Thanks!
Timing belts and chains are not something I'd recommend if you have zero experience with timing stuff. The majority of mistakes will lead to bent valves, also known as a trashed engine that in this case will likely not be worth fixing.
Have someone w experience oversee what you're doing in real time. Conceptually it's not difficult, but it real life, if you lose track of where you are, it usually doesn't end well.
Have someone w experience oversee what you're doing in real time. Conceptually it's not difficult, but it real life, if you lose track of where you are, it usually doesn't end well.
I agree with Derf, unless you just want the experience and you don't care about the outcome. If it ain't broke don't fix it, knock on wood, I've never had ro do a timing chain, even owned a car from New and drove it for 14 years never doing a timing chain, plus around 6 other cars no timing chain maintenance or repair
Your not talkong about a serpentine belt right ? Ive noticed some peopele think there the same thing.
Your not talkong about a serpentine belt right ? Ive noticed some peopele think there the same thing.
I asked because yesterday while doing my brakes a mechanic told me he saw wear on my timing strap belt but this morning i realised I did it in 2023. The strap has shown signs on wear tho so i'm kind of worried lol. Guess i'll just wait and see. I could provide some pictures if anyone is curious too lol
you make me wonder right now if i'm not talking about the serpentine lol. I'll picture it and send it so maybe you could confirm lol? Thanks..
If it's outside the engine and is running around in some bizarre pattern around a bunch of pulleys, you are most definitely discussing the serpentine belt. You cannot see the timing belt without removing the timing belt cover. There is no excuse, French or not, for referring to the serpentine belt as a timing belt. Also, someone above mentioned not needing to change the timing chain. For engines with metal timing chains, replacement is not necessary unless signs of wear, usually exposed by hearing them, are present.
Timing belts, however, are usually made of some type of rubber with plastic teeth that allow the crankshaft to drive the camshafts, balance shafts, water pump and whatever else I'm forgetting.
These typically last 80,000 to 120,000 mi.
He's probably looking at the serpentine belt grooves on the surface that touches the pulleys and sees some cracking in the rubber.
What I see with a lot of rubber parts, not just Saturn parts, for vehicles no longer produced, is that even the new old stock with rubber parts show up with the rubber already dried out. It's because they were manufactured 10-15 years ago and have just sat on a shelf in a warehouse drying out. Most of the aftermarket parts are no different so you take what you can get. I stopped replacing the front LCAs on my 95 Saturn and even just the bushings to the stabilizer bar because even the AC Delco new stock arrives with a manufactured date of 2014 or earlier. Not quite as dried out as the ones I have but close enough to make the replacement more or less pointless.
Sorry for rambling on...hmmmm....
Ramble on, and now's the time, the time is now
To sing my song, I'm going 'round the world, I gotta find my girl
On my way, I've been this way ten years to the day
Ramble on, gotta find the queen of all my dreams
Timing belts, however, are usually made of some type of rubber with plastic teeth that allow the crankshaft to drive the camshafts, balance shafts, water pump and whatever else I'm forgetting.
These typically last 80,000 to 120,000 mi.
He's probably looking at the serpentine belt grooves on the surface that touches the pulleys and sees some cracking in the rubber.
What I see with a lot of rubber parts, not just Saturn parts, for vehicles no longer produced, is that even the new old stock with rubber parts show up with the rubber already dried out. It's because they were manufactured 10-15 years ago and have just sat on a shelf in a warehouse drying out. Most of the aftermarket parts are no different so you take what you can get. I stopped replacing the front LCAs on my 95 Saturn and even just the bushings to the stabilizer bar because even the AC Delco new stock arrives with a manufactured date of 2014 or earlier. Not quite as dried out as the ones I have but close enough to make the replacement more or less pointless.
Sorry for rambling on...hmmmm....
Ramble on, and now's the time, the time is now
To sing my song, I'm going 'round the world, I gotta find my girl
On my way, I've been this way ten years to the day
Ramble on, gotta find the queen of all my dreams
Well it definitly is the serpentine he was talking about then. I'm kinda surprised the mechanic didn't differentiate these two, or just didn't tell me nevertheless. At this point i'm going through the reparations i've made so far and i realise i've changed the timing belt kit in 2023 so... guess the parts were already fairly dried out which is why he thought it'd be needing chance.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post



